How Hacker News stays interesting
Last week I wrote a post called “My parents are Flat-Earthers”,
a history of conspiracy theories in my family.
Someone submitted it to Hacker News,
and it sat at the top for an hour or so.
Then, suddenly, the post dropped to position #26!
Here,
I describe how that happened,
why it happened,
and why it’s a good thing.
Truly my father’s son,
my first reaction to this plunge was:
“it’s a conspiracy!”
After calming down,
I learned that you can reach the moderators at hn@ycombinator.com.
I received a quick reply:
A few things happened with that post:
a moderator put a penalty on it,
and then a software overheated-discussion detector kicked in,
and users flagged it.
Those are primarily about dampening the kinds of discussion that results from articles like this one,
not about the article itself.
Hacker News (but probably not just HN!)
reacts to speculative, exploratory content on controversial topics
with all their own pent-up speculation and anecdotes,
and the problem is that it just gets nasty.
Religious flamewars,
harsh judgements of others (including one’s own grandparents!), blame, etc.
This is not the discussion by which we gratify our intellectual curiosity,
and so it gets cleared away for other threads that might.
My website doesn’t have a comments section.
Reading the comments on that Hacker News post,
you can appreciate why!
It’s a circlejerk.
Most comments were science vs. religion debates,
the kind that only science-types have.
Others were “How do Flat-Earthers explain X?”,
knowing full well that no Flat-Earthers are around to answer.
Many other comments were armchair psychoanalysis,
without the patient present in the room.
Several comments were pretty mean.
“It’s really fucked up he wrote this about his parents,”
or “I hope my kids have the decency not to trash me in a blog post when they’re older.”
I tried hard in my post to describe my family respectfully.
My parents’ ideas are wacky and get what they deserve,
but I tried hard to avoid ad hominem,
and to show that I appreciate my relationship with them.
But were these the comments that triggered the “overheated-discussion detector”?
Perhaps not!
The detector is said to actually fire “when the number of comments on a submission exceeds its score”.
With 211 comments vs. 173 points, my post was way above average.
A simple algorithm which avoids any textual analysis,
but isn’t this terribly ripe for abuse?
I don’t think so.
The overheated-discussion detector was outweighed by humans.
The moderator’s reply showed he had spent time and thought,
reading the post and comments before judging.
Burying this post was closer to curation than censorship.
See the difference:
unlike censorship, I received a polite explanation for it;
and unlike censorship, burying is a visible action, right there on the homepage!
My new post was sandwiched between much older, un-buried posts,
and you can frequently see such posts whenever you open the homepage:
If you want to blame Facebook and YouTube for allowing the spread of wild conspiracy theories,
it’s hard to also blame calmer forums like Hacker News for moderation.
Thanks to moderation,
when I open news.ycombinator.com right now,
I’m pleased to see interesting new posts about C, Chopin, and concurrency;
and no new posts about fake news, anti-vaxxers, or Flat Earth.
Similar posts
My parents are Flat-Earthers
For decades, my parents have been working up to Flat-Earther beliefs. From Egyptology to Jehovah’s Witnesses to theories that human built the Moon billions of years in the future. Surprisingly, it doesn’t affect their successful lives very much. For me, it’s a fun family pastime. 2019-01-20
I hate telephones
I hate telephones. Some rational reasons: lack of authentication, no spam filtering, forced synchronous communication. But also just a visceral fear. 2017-11-08
Granddad died today
Granddad died. The unspoken practice of death-by-dehydration in the NHS. The Liverpool Care Pathway. Assisted dying in the UK. The importance of planning in end-of-life care. 2017-05-19
The hacker hype cycle
I got started with simple web development, but because enamored with increasingly esoteric programming concepts, leading to a “trough of hipster technologies” before returning to more productive work. 2019-03-23
What does the dot do in JavaScript?
foo.bar, foo.bar(), or foo.bar = baz - what do they mean? A deep dive into prototypical inheritance and getters/setters. 2020-11-01
The dots do matter: how to scam a Gmail user
Gmail’s “dots don’t matter” feature lets scammers create an account on, say, Netflix, with your email address but different dots. Results in convincing phishing emails. 2018-04-07
More by Jim
What does the dot do in JavaScript?
foo.bar, foo.bar(), or foo.bar = baz - what do they mean? A deep dive into prototypical inheritance and getters/setters. 2020-11-01
Smear phishing: a new Android vulnerability
Trick Android to display an SMS as coming from any contact. Convincing phishing vuln, but still unpatched. 2020-08-06
A probabilistic pub quiz for nerds
A “true or false” quiz where you respond with your confidence level, and the optimal strategy is to report your true belief. 2020-04-26
Time is running out to catch COVID-19
Simulation shows it’s rational to deliberately infect yourself with COVID-19 early on to get treatment, but after healthcare capacity is exceeded, it’s better to avoid infection. Includes interactive parameters and visualizations. 2020-03-14
The inception bar: a new phishing method
A new phishing technique that displays a fake URL bar in Chrome for mobile. A key innovation is the “scroll jail” that traps the user in a fake browser. 2019-04-27
The hacker hype cycle
I got started with simple web development, but because enamored with increasingly esoteric programming concepts, leading to a “trough of hipster technologies” before returning to more productive work. 2019-03-23
Project C-43: the lost origins of asymmetric crypto
Bob invents asymmetric cryptography by playing loud white noise to obscure Alice’s message, which he can cancel out but an eavesdropper cannot. This idea, published in 1944 by Walter Koenig Jr., is the forgotten origin of asymmetric crypto. 2019-02-16
How Hacker News stays interesting
Hacker News buried my post on conspiracy theories in my family due to overheated discussion, not censorship. Moderation keeps the site focused on interesting technical content. 2019-01-26
My parents are Flat-Earthers
For decades, my parents have been working up to Flat-Earther beliefs. From Egyptology to Jehovah’s Witnesses to theories that human built the Moon billions of years in the future. Surprisingly, it doesn’t affect their successful lives very much. For me, it’s a fun family pastime. 2019-01-20
The dots do matter: how to scam a Gmail user
Gmail’s “dots don’t matter” feature lets scammers create an account on, say, Netflix, with your email address but different dots. Results in convincing phishing emails. 2018-04-07
The sorry state of OpenSSL usability
OpenSSL’s inadequate documentation, confusing key formats, and deprecated interfaces make it difficult to use, despite its importance. 2017-12-02
I hate telephones
I hate telephones. Some rational reasons: lack of authentication, no spam filtering, forced synchronous communication. But also just a visceral fear. 2017-11-08
The Three Ts of Time, Thought and Typing: measuring cost on the web
Businesses often tout “free” services, but the real costs come in terms of time, thought, and typing required from users. Reducing these “Three Ts” is key to improving sign-up flows and increasing conversions. 2017-10-26
Granddad died today
Granddad died. The unspoken practice of death-by-dehydration in the NHS. The Liverpool Care Pathway. Assisted dying in the UK. The importance of planning in end-of-life care. 2017-05-19
How do I call a program in C, setting up standard pipes?
A C function to create a new process, set up its standard input/output/error pipes, and return a struct containing the process ID and pipe file descriptors. 2017-02-17
Your syntax highlighter is wrong
Syntax highlighters make value judgments about code. Most highlighters judge that comments are cruft, and try to hide them. Most diff viewers judge that code deletions are bad. 2014-05-11
Want to build a fantastic product using LLMs? I work at
Granola where we're building the future IDE for knowledge work. Come and work with us!
Read more or
get in touch! This page copyright James Fisher 2019. Content is not associated with my employer. Found an error? Edit this page.
TigYog
Kickabout